domains / families / science / rebuttal-guidance

rebuttal-guidance

separate

Provides actionable peer-review rebuttal guidance (not full rebuttal prose) using conditional persuasion P(Z|X,Y): match reviewer mindset X, recommend strategy Y, optionally ground in manuscript evidence and similar successful historical (review, rebuttal) pairs. Use when the user pastes reviewer comments, asks for rebuttal help, rebuttal guidance, response to reviewers, how to reply to R1.W2, OpenReview rebuttal, or the reviewer ignored the rebuttal.

When to use

• User pastes Weaknesses / Questions from ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML, EMNLP, etc.
• User asks how to respond to a specific reviewer comment.
• User wants a structured plan before writing rebuttal prose.
• User asks which tone or evidence strategy fits a harsh vs. open reviewer.
• User says "reviewer ignored my rebuttal" and wants to recalibrate.

When not to use

• User wants full rebuttal text copied verbatim → output guidance first; warn
• User asks to evaluate a research idea → use `idea-evaluator`.
• User asks for pre-submission paper review → use `pre-submission-reviewer`.
• No review text provided → ask for it first.

Skill page

Source