domains / families / science / atc-review-process

atc-review-process

separate

Use when reasoning about how an ATC (ACM SIGOPS Annual Technical Conference, formerly USENIX ATC) submission is evaluated — the two-round extended-abstract model, the round-one gate by two reviewers, the round-two read by 3-4 reviewers, double-blind reviewing, rebuttal, conditional acceptance with shepherding, and how ATC differs from OSDI/SOSP/NSDI.

When to use

• reasoning about ATC submission evaluation
• understanding the two-round extended-abstract model
• analyzing round-one gate by two reviewers
• analyzing round-two read by 3-4 reviewers
• understanding double-blind reviewing
• understanding rebuttal process
• understanding conditional acceptance with shepherding
• comparing ATC to OSDI, SOSP, NSDI, and EuroSys

When not to use

• writing the extended abstract
• designing the system
• performing measurements
• appealing a rejection

Skill page

Source