domains / families / research / vis-review-process

vis-review-process

separate

Use when reasoning about how an IEEE VIS full-paper submission is evaluated, covering the two-phase review that mirrors IEEE TVCG, the primary/secondary/external (and 2026 student) reviewer roles, the six-area routing through Area Paper Chairs, the conditional-accept second round, and how VIS's journal-integrated process differs from a single accept/reject conference and from CHI/CVPR.

When to use

• reasoning about IEEE VIS full-paper submission evaluation
• understanding the two-phase review process
• identifying primary, secondary, external, and student reviewer roles
• explaining six-area routing through Area Paper Chairs
• analyzing the conditional-accept second round
• comparing VIS process to CHI and CVPR

When not to use

• single accept/reject conference processes
• CHI rebuttal and revise-and-resubmit processes
• CVPR single-decision and fixed rebuttal processes
• pre-2021 separate SciVis, InfoVis, and VAST conference processes

Skill page

Source