domains / families / research / jaar-revision-and-response

jaar-revision-and-response

separate

Use when revising a Journal of the American Academy of Religion (JAAR) article after a revise-and-resubmit and writing the response to readers' reports. Reviewers come from different traditions and methods, so the response must satisfy each on its own terms while protecting the article's argument and its broad significance. Plans the revision and response; it does not fabricate sources.

When to use

• Planning the revision and response letter after an R&R decision
• Addressing readers' reports from different methodological traditions
• Writing the cover note to the editor
• Reconciling cross-method reader requests
• Protecting the article's broad significance against over-specialization

When not to use

• Fabricating sources

Skill page

Source