domains / families / research / jape-rebuttal

jape-rebuttal

separate

Use when drafting the response letter for a Journal of Applied Econometrics (JAE) revise-and-resubmit — replying to single-blind anonymous referees and the Editor-in-Chief on applied-econometrics objections (identification on real data, inference, robustness) while keeping the JAE Data Archive package in sync with every revised result.

When to use

• Drafting JAE revise-and-resubmit response letters
• Replying to single-blind anonymous referees and Editor-in-Chief
• Addressing applied-econometrics objections on identification, inference, and robustness
• Triaging referee comments into identification, inference, robustness, and reproducibility lanes
• Keeping JAE Data Archive package consistent with revised results

When not to use

• Treating a reject as a resubmission opportunity without an Editor's invitation
• Arguing identification verbally instead of adding a test
• Bloating the 35-page main text with new robustness instead of using the appendix
• Letting revised tables and the replication package drift apart

Skill page

Source