domains / families / research / ceq-rebuttal

ceq-rebuttal

separate

Use when drafting the response letter for a revise-and-resubmit (R&R) at 《经济学(季刊)》 (China Economic Quarterly, CEQ) — where reviewers are typically field-trained and press hardest on identification, modern-DID compliance, and inference. Structures a point-by-point reply that concedes or rebuts with evidence. Use only after the manuscript itself has been revised.

When to use

• Drafting CEQ R&R response letters
• Structuring point-by-point replies to reviewer comments
• Addressing identification and modern-DID concerns
• Responding to inference and clustering issues
• Handling conflicting reviewer opinions
• Mapping high-frequency CEQ comments to response strategies

When not to use

• Generating response letters before the manuscript is revised
• Claiming modifications without corresponding manuscript changes
• Using emotional or unprofessional rebuttals
• Ignoring secondary reviewer comments

Skill page

Source