domains / families / research / aer-rebuttal

aer-rebuttal

separate

Use when responding to a Revise & Resubmit decision from AER, AER:Insights, or an AEJ, and a point-by-point response letter plus aligned manuscript revisions are needed. Handles triage, the concede / clarify / push-back decision, and the response-letter format that editors actually read.

When to use

• An R&R decision has arrived
• A "reject and resubmit" requires a structured response
• A conditional acceptance comes with minor revisions
• The user needs to decide which reviewer comments to concede, clarify, or push back on
• Initial submission (use `aer-submission`)
• Pre-emptive robustness drafting (use `aer-robustness`)
• Writing referee reports as a reviewer (different conventions)

When not to use

• Initial submission
• Pre-emptive robustness drafting
• Writing referee reports as a reviewer

Skill page

Source