domains / families / research / rof-rebuttal

rof-rebuttal

separate

Use when drafting a Review of Finance response letter and revision plan after an R&R, especially under the two-round philosophy, top-three-finance standards, code/data conditions, and page-cap constraints.

When to use

• Drafting RoF response letter
• Sequencing revisions
• Drafting point-by-point response
• Handling second-round new concerns
• Managing 60-page cap
• Updating replication programs and data

When not to use

• Treating suggestions as binding while under-addressing major concerns
• Drafting letter before revised manuscript exists
• Saving key results for round two
• Defensive pushback instead of new evidence

Skill page

Source