domains / families / research / ecj-rebuttal

ecj-rebuttal

separate

Use when a The Economic Journal (EJ) decision letter (R&R or reject-with-encouragement) has arrived and you need to draft the response-to-referees letter and revision plan. Structures the response and the diff; it does not redo the analysis (route back to ecj-identification / ecj-theory-model / ecj-robustness first).

When to use

• drafting response-to-referees letter
• creating revision plan
• structuring point-by-point responses
• summarizing changes for editor
• handling EJ-typical demands
• planning replication readiness

When not to use

• redoing analysis
• writing response letter before doing revisions
• skipping or merging referee points
• defensive or dismissive tone
• conceding correct results without evidence
• promising future work instead of current analysis
• dismissing exposition requests as cosmetic
• ignoring editor's prioritization

Skill page

Source