domains / families / research / jms-rebuttal

jms-rebuttal

separate

Use when drafting the response-to-reviewers and revision for a Journal of Management Studies (JMS) R&R — turning a developmental, often multi-round decision letter into a point-by-point response that satisfies the handling editor. Drafts the rebuttal; it does not re-plan the review reading (jms-review-process) or rebuild the theory from scratch (jms-theory-development).

When to use

• drafting the response letter
• point-by-point response to reviewers
• handling reviewer disagreements
• pushing back on weakening changes
• re-sharpening theoretical contribution
• showing decisive progress in round 2+
• surfacing reviewer conflicts to the editor

When not to use

• re-planning the review reading
• rebuilding the theory from scratch

Skill page

Source