domains / families / research / jcf-rebuttal

jcf-rebuttal

separate

Use when preparing a revise-and-resubmit response for the Journal of Corporate Finance (JCF) — a point-by-point reply to two-or-more single-anonymized reviewers and the handling editor, reconciling divergent demands without over-claiming. It structures the response letter and revision plan; it does not run new analysis on its own.

When to use

• preparing a revise-and-resubmit response for JCF
• writing a point-by-point reply to reviewers and editor
• reconciling divergent or conflicting reviewer demands
• mapping each comment to a concrete revision
• structuring the response letter and revision plan
• addressing identification, magnitude, sample, mechanism, and framing comments

When not to use

• running new analysis on its own
• arguing without changing the paper
• silently ignoring points the editor cares about
• caving to one reviewer in a way that breaks the other's concern
• letting the revision quietly over-claim beyond the design

Skill page

Source