domains / families / research / respol-rebuttal

respol-rebuttal

separate

Use when drafting the response to a Research Policy (RP) decision letter — converting double-blind referee and handling-editor comments into a point-by-point response and a revision plan that protects the innovation-studies contribution. Builds the response strategy; it is the terminal skill in the pack.

When to use

• Drafting response to RP decision letter
• Converting referee comments into point-by-point response
• Creating revision plan
• Reconciling conflicting referee requests
• Addressing handling editor summary points
• Defending innovation-studies contribution

When not to use

• Arguing with referees instead of resolving concerns
• Fixing wording while leaving substantive challenges unanswered
• Conceding broadly until contribution disappears
• Ignoring editor's summary
• Claiming changes without showing location in manuscript
• Promising future work instead of doing analysis

Skill page

Source