domains / families / research / isr-rebuttal

isr-rebuttal

separate

Use when planning and drafting the response to an Information Systems Research (ISR) revise-and-resubmit — prioritizing the Senior Editor's binding concerns, addressing genre-specific reviewer asks (assumptions/proofs, identification/validity, evaluation), updating the contribution statement, and using the electronic companion. Drafts the revision and response; it runs after isr-review-process.

When to use

• Planning and drafting ISR revise-and-resubmit response
• Prioritizing Senior Editor's binding concerns
• Addressing genre-specific reviewer asks
• Updating the contribution statement
• Using the electronic companion for new material
• Building a revision control ledger
• Writing a point-by-point response letter

When not to use

• Drafting the letter before revising the manuscript
• Treating reviewers as equal voices over the Senior Editor
• Cosmetic responses without manuscript edits
• Exceeding the page cap instead of using the electronic companion
• Accepting mutually inconsistent reviewer requests without rationale

Skill page

Source