domains / families / research / jmis-rebuttal

jmis-rebuttal

separate

Use when planning and drafting the response to a Journal of Management Information Systems (JMIS) major/minor revision — a point-by-point reply to the EIC, Associate Editor, and double-anonymized referees that resolves identification, measurement, contribution, and robustness concerns. Plans and drafts the response; revisit earlier jmis-* skills to execute the underlying fixes.

When to use

• Planning response to JMIS revision letters
• Drafting point-by-point replies to referees
• Resolving identification and measurement concerns
• Addressing contribution and robustness issues
• Reconciling conflicting referee comments
• Structuring response for EIC adjudication

When not to use

• Executing underlying data analysis fixes
• Performing new statistical analyses
• Rewriting manuscript prose style
• Creating tables and figures

Skill page

Source