domains / families / research / jacs-revision

jacs-revision

separate

Use when a decision letter/referee reports arrive for a Journal of the American Chemical Society (JACS) manuscript, to plan experiments and draft the point-by-point response. Structures the revision and rebuttal — it does not fabricate data or guarantee acceptance.

When to use

• triage referee comments into experiments vs edits vs rebuttals
• draft the point-by-point response letter
• decide whether to appeal or resubmit elsewhere
• plan new experiments for rigor-critical comments
• create a JACS revision ledger
• structure the response letter with opening and point-by-point sections

When not to use

• fabricate data
• guarantee acceptance

Skill page

Source