domains / families / research / advmat-revision

advmat-revision

separate

Use when responding to Advanced Materials reviewer reports and an editor's decision — major or minor revision, or a rejection with a resubmission or transfer path. Structures the response and the manuscript changes; does not perform the underlying new experiments.

When to use

• Responding to Advanced Materials reviewer reports
• Handling major or minor revision decisions
• Managing rejections with resubmission or transfer paths
• Structuring point-by-point responses
• Addressing requests for additional characterization or benchmarking
• Drafting rebuttal language for coauthors
• Deciding between appeal and transfer for rejections

When not to use

• Performing underlying new experiments
• Adding unrelated new results that reopen length budget

Skill page

Source