domains / families / research / pods-review-process

pods-review-process

separate

Use when reasoning about how an ACM PODS submission is evaluated, covering lightweight double-anonymous review, the multi-cycle-per-year calendar, the two reviewing rounds within a cycle, the 48-hour rebuttal, the accept/reject/revision decision with a shepherded revision, PACMMOD-track publication, and how PODS differs from SIGMOD's rounds and ICDT's process.

When to use

• reasoning about ACM PODS submission evaluation
• understanding lightweight double-anonymous review
• modeling the multi-cycle-per-year calendar
• explaining the two reviewing rounds within a cycle
• describing the 48-hour rebuttal window
• interpreting accept/reject/revision decisions
• understanding shepherded revision process
• comparing PODS to SIGMOD and ICDT processes

When not to use

• evaluating systems performance benchmarks
• submitting to SIGMOD or VLDB
• appealing a rejection decision
• adding new proofs during rebuttal

Skill page

Source