domains / families / research / anmath-revision

anmath-revision

separate

Use when responding to an Annals of Mathematics referee report — revising the manuscript to close gaps or strengthen results and writing a point-by-point reply. Drafts the revision and response after the text is fixed; does not invent significance the result lacks (see anmath-scope-fit).

When to use

• responding to an Annals of Mathematics referee report
• revising the manuscript to close gaps
• strengthening results
• writing a point-by-point reply
• addressing queries
• fixing questionable steps
• adding missing citations
• showing exactly what changed

When not to use

• inventing significance the result lacks
• writing the reply before fixing the mathematics
• arguing a genuine gap away
• patching a gap with 'it is easy to see'
• silently ignoring a referee remark
• claiming the original wrong theorem still holds without proof

Skill page

Source