domains / families / research / fcr-revision-and-rebuttal

fcr-revision-and-rebuttal

separate

Use when writing the response to a Field Crops Research (FCR) revision decision (major or minor) and revising the manuscript. FCR reviewers commonly press on scope/generality, statistics and G×E, reproducibility detail, and a discussion that interprets rather than repeats. The response must address every point while protecting the contribution. Structures the response letter; it does not fabricate new results.

When to use

• writing response to FCR revision decision
• revising manuscript for FCR
• reconciling conflicting reviewer requests
• writing cover note to editor
• addressing scope and generality concerns
• addressing statistics and GxE concerns
• addressing reproducibility detail
• interpreting discussion rather than repeating results

When not to use

• fabricating new results

Skill page

Source