domains / families / research / mind-revision-and-response

mind-revision-and-response

separate

Use when responding to a Mind decision — a revise-and-resubmit, a reject-with-encouragement, or referee reports to address before resubmitting. The response must answer expert philosophical objections without weakening the thesis, while keeping the manuscript prepared for triple-anonymous review. Structures the revision and the response letter; it does not fabricate new arguments.

When to use

• responding to a Mind decision
• planning the revision after a revise-and-resubmit
• planning the revision after a reject-with-encouragement
• addressing referee reports before resubmitting
• deciding whom to follow when referees disagree
• addressing an objection that would change the conclusion
• writing the response letter
• writing the cover note for resubmission

When not to use

• fabricating new arguments

Skill page

Source