domains / families / research / jfm-referee-strategy

jfm-referee-strategy

separate

Use when anticipating the microstructure referee's objections for a Journal of Financial Markets (JFM) manuscript — a pre-submission pre-mortem and, post-decision, a triage of the report. Anticipates and triages; it does not invent evidence or citations.

When to use

• pre-submission pre-mortem
• triage of the report
• surface objections a microstructure insider will raise
• triage which comments are fatal, fixable, or push-back
• estimate whether the asks are within an R&R's reach
• read the signal in the editor's letter
• plan for microstructure specialist and broader-finance reader profiles

When not to use

• invent evidence
• invent citations

Skill page

Source