domains / families / research / dac-author-response

dac-author-response

separate

Use when handling reviewer feedback for an ACM/IEEE Design Automation Conference (DAC) Research Manuscript — writing a concise, evidence-first rebuttal IF the cycle runs an author-response period (verify; DAC has historically not), and otherwise converting DAC reviews into a targeted response-to-reviewers when rerouting a rejected paper to ICCAD, DATE, ASP-DAC, or a journal.

When to use

• writing concise evidence-first rebuttals
• converting DAC reviews into targeted responses
• rerouting rejected papers to ICCAD, DATE, ASP-DAC, or journals
• addressing baseline fairness and benchmark credibility
• creating fix lists for resubmission
• writing journal response letters for TCAD/TODAES

When not to use

• arguing novelty by assertion without QoR delta
• blaming benchmarks for poor results
• introducing author-revealing information in double-blind responses
• promising experiments that cannot be run before camera-ready

Skill page

Source