domains / families / research / orgstud-review-process

orgstud-review-process

separate

Use when calibrating expectations for the Organization Studies (OS) review cycle — desk-screen odds, the developmental double-anonymized process, decision types, and how to read what reviewers and the handling editor are signalling. Sets expectations and reading strategy; it does not draft the response (see orgstud-rebuttal).

When to use

• Calibrating desk-reject odds and timeline
• Reading decision letters for editor signals
• Distinguishing major-but-encouraging R&R from high-risk reject-with-resubmission
• Deciding whether to revise for OS or reposition to a sibling journal
• Understanding OS double-anonymized developmental review process
• Interpreting theory-first reviewer comments
• Separating essential editor-flagged asks from optional ones

When not to use

• Drafting the response to reviewers
• Developing theory
• Framing contribution
• Routing repositioning workflow

Skill page

Source