domains / families / research / imc-review-process

imc-review-process

separate

Use when reasoning about how an ACM IMC submission is evaluated, covering double-blind multi-round review, the Accept / One-Shot-Revision / Reject decision categories, the reviewer-champion rule and bounded action points, early rejection of consensus-reject papers, shepherding for artifact availability, and how IMC's two-deadline model differs from SIGCOMM/NSDI cycles.

When to use

• reasoning about ACM IMC submission evaluation
• understanding double-blind multi-round review
• interpreting Accept, One-Shot-Revision, and Reject decisions
• applying the reviewer-champion rule
• managing bounded action points for revision
• handling early rejection of consensus-reject papers
• understanding shepherding for artifact availability
• comparing IMC's two-deadline model to SIGCOMM/NSDI

When not to use

• writing author responses
• designing new measurement studies
• submitting to SIGCOMM or NSDI
• appealing a rejection

Skill page

Source