domains / families / research / jwe-rebuttal

jwe-rebuttal

separate

Use when responding to 《世界经济》 (The Journal of World Economy) referee reports (R&R) — structuring a point-by-point response letter that addresses the journal's characteristic challenges (open-economy fit, shift-share / gravity inference, transmission channel, GVC measurement). Use after the manuscript has actually been revised.

When to use

• Structuring point-by-point response letters
• Addressing open-economy fit challenges
• Responding to shift-share and gravity inference critiques
• Handling transmission channel and GVC measurement questions
• Resolving conflicting referee opinions
• Drafting rebuttals for R&R reports

When not to use

• Writing response letters before manuscript revision is complete
• Providing empty acknowledgments without substantive changes
• Avoiding methodological critiques on identification or inference

Skill page

Source