domains / families / research / orgsci-rebuttal

orgsci-rebuttal

separate

Use after an Organization Science R&R to plan the revision and draft the point-by-point response letter, following the journal's codified author-response norms — verbatim italic quoting of each comment, no duplicated responses across reviewers, and a non-combative, non-effusive tone, while prioritizing the autonomous senior editor's concerns.

When to use

• plan revisions after R&R
• draft point-by-point response letter
• handle reviewer disagreements
• format response letter for Organization Science
• prioritize senior editor concerns
• map comments to manuscript changes

When not to use

• drafting letter before manuscript revision
• duplicating responses across reviewers
• combative or effusive tone
• ignoring senior editor prioritization

Skill page

Source