domains / families / research / mksc-rebuttal

mksc-rebuttal

separate

Use when drafting the revision and response letter after a Marketing Science revise-and-resubmit — structuring point-by-point responses to the Senior/Associate Editor and reviewers across a multi-round process, especially on assumptions, identification, counterfactuals, computation, and replication. Drafts the response after revising; it does not interpret the decision (mksc-review-process).

When to use

• Drafting R&R response letters
• Structuring point-by-point reviewer responses
• Reconciling conflicting reviewer demands
• Addressing identification and assumption objections
• Documenting computation and replication updates
• Defending prior changes in later rounds

When not to use

• Interpreting the decision
• Writing the response before revising the manuscript
• Answering identification objections with citations only
• Skipping inconvenient comments
• De-blinding the manuscript

Skill page

Source