domains / families / research / jole-rebuttal
jole-rebuttal
separate
Use when drafting a response letter to a Journal of Labor Economics (JOLE) revise-and-resubmit — addressing single-blind labor referees point by point under the journal's word economy. Strategy and structure; it does not run new estimations for you.
When to use
- Drafting a response letter to a JOLE revise-and-resubmit
- Addressing single-blind labor referees point by point
- Converting new results into a referee-by-referee response
- Reconciling demands from disagreeing referees
- Deciding how much to concede versus defend on labor-identification critiques
- Structuring a cover note to the editor
- Formatting point-by-point replies with manuscript locations
- Managing word economy for the revised manuscript
When not to use
- Running new estimations
- Re-anonymizing the manuscript
- Adding exhibits that exceed the word cap
- Conceding identification flaws with words instead of evidence
- Ignoring one referee because another disagrees
- Silently dropping a result a referee questioned
Skill page
Source