domains / families / research / jme-rebuttal

jme-rebuttal

separate

Use after a Journal of Monetary Economics (JME) revise-and-resubmit to plan the response letter and revision — given JME's distinctive "up or out" rule (the resubmission ends in acceptance or rejection, no second R&R) and the ~50% publication-likelihood signal an R&R carries.

When to use

• JME revise-and-resubmit response planning
• Drafting response-to-referees letter
• Prioritizing make-or-break referee points
• Managing JME page and exhibit limits
• JME R&R rebuttal strategy

When not to use

• Second round of revise-and-resubmit
• Deflecting major identification critiques
• Exceeding 40 pages or 10 exhibits in main text
• Defensive or combative tone toward referees

Skill page

Source