domains / families / research / jfqa-rebuttal

jfqa-rebuttal

separate

Use when planning the strategy and structure for a Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis (JFQA) revise-and-resubmit response — point-by-point replies to double-anonymous referees and the handling Managing Editor, new robustness/identification evidence, and code-archive readiness.

When to use

• JFQA revise-and-resubmit response
• point-by-point replies to double-anonymous referees
• responses to the handling Managing Editor
• new robustness and identification evidence
• code-archive readiness
• comment triage and sequencing
• re-estimating tables for inference complaints
• scaling economic magnitude

When not to use

• defensive letters that argue rather than revise
• selectively answering only easy comments
• new results not wired into the reproducible pipeline
• re-introducing author identity in the revised file

Skill page

Source