domains / families / research / jegeo-rebuttal

jegeo-rebuttal

separate

Use when a Journal of Economic Geography (JEG) decision letter arrives and you must plan a revision and response that satisfies a cross-disciplinary referee pair. Structures the rebuttal; it does not invent results or concede the core claim.

When to use

• triage R&R or major-revision reports
• plan revision and response for JEG
• structure rebuttal for cross-disciplinary referees
• decide on spatial work requests
• draft response letter for editor and referees
• balance economist and geographer feedback
• classify comments by community and demand
• handle conflicting referee requests

When not to use

• invent results
• concede the core claim
• silently ignore unreasonable comments
• report only favorable spatial checks
• promise changes without showing evidence

Skill page

Source