domains / families / research / jae-rebuttal

jae-rebuttal

separate

Use when planning revisions and drafting the point-by-point response for a Journal of Accounting and Economics (JAE) revise-and-resubmit — prioritizing the editor's identification and contribution concerns, satisfying economics-trained reviewers with new tests, and noting that resubmissions carry no submission fee.

When to use

• planning JAE revise-and-resubmit revisions
• drafting point-by-point response letters
• addressing identification and mechanism concerns
• reconciling conflicting reviewer requests
• testing alternative explanations empirically
• preparing cover letters to the editor

When not to use

• unsolicited new manuscript submissions
• submitting to JAR, TAR, or Review of Accounting Studies
• unmasking authorship in responses

Skill page

Source