domains / families / research / io-rebuttal

io-rebuttal

separate

Use when writing the response to an International Organization (IO) revise-and-resubmit. IO R&Rs come from expert IR referees whose anonymous reviews the editors return with a decision letter, and the editor adjudicates. The response must convert each reviewer on the IR theory and design without alienating the editor, keep the manuscript double-blind, and keep results and proofs re-runnable for IO's pre-final-acceptance verification. Structures the response; it does not fabricate new results.

When to use

• Planning the revision and response memo after an R&R decision
• Addressing disagreements between rationalist and constructivist referees
• Responding to requests for analyses or model changes
• Writing the cover note to the editor summarizing the revision
• Reconciling paradigm-driven conflicts in the response

When not to use

• Fabricating new results
• Tasks not related to IO revise-and-resubmit responses

Skill page

Source