domains / families / research / aeri-rebuttal

aeri-rebuttal

separate

Use when responding to an American Economic Review: Insights (AER: Insights) conditional-accept decision — addressing the editor's letter within the short window, usually without a second referee round. Drafts a concise, decisive response and revision plan; it does not redo the analysis (see aeri-robustness / aeri-identification).

When to use

• responding to AER: Insights conditional-accept decision
• addressing editor's letter within short window
• drafting concise and decisive response
• creating revision plan
• mapping requested changes to concrete edits
• finalizing replication package for AEA Data Editor
• deciding next steps after a reject

When not to use

• redoing the analysis
• arguing with the editor as if multi-round R&R
• adding text or exhibits that re-breach word or exhibit caps
• writing long defensive response letters
• letting requested additions sprawl the paper beyond its single insight

Skill page

Source