domains / families / research / ngeo-scope-fit

ngeo-scope-fit

separate

Use when deciding whether an Earth-science result clears Nature Geoscience's broad-interest, cross-disciplinary Earth-system gate, or whether it belongs in a community journal such as JGR, GRL, or Communications Earth & Environment. Diagnoses venue fit; does not write or frame the result.

When to use

• Deciding venue fit for Earth-science results
• Assessing Nature Geoscience scope fit
• Evaluating broad cross-disciplinary interest
• Checking evidence bar for quantitative uncertainty
• Stress-testing the gate with neighbor and displacement tests
• Determining if a result is regional or incremental

When not to use

• Writing the result
• Framing the result

Skill page

Source