domains / families / research / icsme-review-process

icsme-review-process

separate

Use when reasoning about how an IEEE ICSME research submission is evaluated, covering double-anonymous review, the early-decision cut that issues Accept/Reject before the rebuttal, the "Response Recommended" author-response period, the single-round accept/reject model with no Major Revision, and how ICSME's process differs from FSE's journal-style round and ICSE's cycles.

When to use

• reasoning about ICSME evaluation
• understanding double-anonymous review
• interpreting early-decision cut
• planning for Response Recommended period
• comparing ICSME to FSE and ICSE
• reading review packets
• identifying author leverage points

When not to use

• planning for Major Revision rounds
• submitting to FSE or ICSE
• appealing after rejection
• promising new experiments in rebuttal

Skill page

Source