domains / families / research / er-reviewer-lens

er-reviewer-lens

separate

Use when self-auditing a 《经济研究》 manuscript before submission against the high-frequency, structural reviewer criticisms recurrent at this journal.

When to use

• Self-auditing a 《经济研究》 manuscript before submission
• Checking for high-frequency structural reviewer criticisms
• Systematic review after rejection to identify high-frequency pitfalls
• Peer review among collaborators using a unified standard
• Pre-submission self-check of theoretical positioning
• Pre-submission self-check of identification strategy
• Pre-submission self-check of mechanism and heterogeneity
• Pre-submission self-check of data, robustness, and writing norms

When not to use

• Speculating about specific reviewer preferences
• Simulating a specific reviewer
• Post-rejection analysis only (intended for pre-submission)
• Surface-level fixes without addressing underlying issues
• Ignoring theoretical positioning in favor of technical details
• Avoiding fragile conclusions by hoping reviewers miss them

Skill page

Source