domains / families / research / er-rebuttal

er-rebuttal

separate

Use when responding to reviewer and editorial-board reports for an 《经济研究》 (Economic Research Journal) R&R — sequencing manuscript revision before letter writing, drafting point-by-point replies in the accept / partial-accept / decline modes, prioritizing 编委 theory-positioning comments, and deciding whether new results go in the body or an appendix. 使用时机：收到《经济研究》外审或编委意见、准备修订正文并撰写逐条回复信、或多轮修改中回复与正文出现不一致时。

When to use

• Responding to 《经济研究》 R&R
• Sequencing manuscript revision before letter writing
• Drafting point-by-point replies
• Prioritizing 编委 theory-positioning comments
• Deciding whether new results go in body or appendix
• Handling accept, partial-accept, or decline modes
• Creating opinion-revision comparison tables

When not to use

• Initial manuscript submission
• Writing the main body of the paper from scratch
• Responding to journals other than 《经济研究》

Skill page

Source