domains / families / research / ci-revision-and-response

ci-revision-and-response

separate

Use when revising a Critical Inquiry (CI) essay after a decision and writing the response to readers and editors. CI acceptance typically follows author revisions, and the editors-in-chief read closely, so the revision must strengthen the intervention and the response must address every point without diluting the argument. Structures the revision and response; it does not fabricate new readings or evidence.

When to use

• revising a Critical Inquiry essay after a decision
• writing the response to readers and editors
• reconciling disagreeing readers' reports
• writing the cover note to the editors summarizing the revision
• addressing a request that would blunt the central claim

When not to use

• fabricating new readings or evidence

Skill page

Source