domains / families / research / aejmac-rebuttal

aejmac-rebuttal

separate

Use when an American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics (AEJ: Macro) decision letter has arrived (R&R or reject-with-comments) and you need a response-letter strategy and revision plan. Plans the rebuttal and revision; it does not run new identification, model, or robustness work itself (route to those skills).

When to use

• R&R response-letter strategy
• reject-with-comments revision plan
• reconciling conflicting referee reports
• converting macro objections into a revision plan
• triaging comments into a table
• mapping comments to macro skills
• writing a point-by-point response letter
• reconciling referee conflicts with coeditor guidance

When not to use

• running new identification work
• running new model work
• running new robustness work

Skill page

Source