domains / families / research / phg-critical-intervention

phg-critical-intervention

separate

Use when making the critical move at the heart of a Progress in Human Geography (PiHG) review essay — naming what the field misses, mistakes, or takes for granted, and re-ordering the debate. Sharpens the critical turn; it does not build the synthetic spine (see phg-argument-synthesis) or frame the forward agenda (see phg-contribution-framing).

When to use

• naming what the field misses, mistakes, or takes for granted
• re-ordering the debate
• sharpening the critical turn
• deciding what the field has been getting wrong
• distinguishing genuine critique from mere summary-with-attitude

When not to use

• building the synthetic spine
• framing the forward agenda

Skill page

Source