domains / families / research / jme-contribution-framing
jme-contribution-framing
separate
Use when sharpening the "what is new and why it matters for macro/policy" claim of a Journal of Monetary Economics (JME) manuscript — turning a result into a first-order monetary-economics contribution that clears a single-blind, two-referee, "up or out" process.
When to use
- sharpening the 'what is new and why it matters for macro/policy' claim
- turning a result into a first-order monetary-economics contribution
- sharpening the contribution claim for JME
- framing the paper to survive a desk screen
- convincing two expert referees
- justifying an R&R invitation
- translating the result into who learns what, which mechanism changes, and which alternative explanation is ruled out
- comparing against JIE, RED, and AEJ Macro for sibling guard
When not to use
- giving submission-ready advice until the pack's resources/official-source-map.md has been checked
- giving submission-ready advice until the manuscript has one concrete fix for the largest venue-specific risk
Skill page
Source