domains / families / research / dsh-deepread

dsh-deepread

combined

精读一本书或一篇文章：提取核心观点、论证结构与关键论据。当用户要求「精读/分析这篇文章」「提取核心观点」「梳理论证逻辑」「做知识地图」「用费曼读书法读书」时使用本技能。五种模式：quick 快速要点 / deep 深度精读 / map 知识地图 / feynman 费曼读书法 / book 全书精读。Deep-reading assistant for books and articles: extract core claims, arguments and evidence. Use for evidence-first reading of articles, books, PDFs, web pages, or document sets, with knowledge maps and Feynman checks.

When to use

• Use when a user asks to read, summarize, or critically analyze an article, book, PDF, web page, or document collection.
• Use when important claims must remain connected to evidence and source locations.
• Use when the user wants a mind map, concept map, comparison matrix, or structured study notes.
• Use when the user wants to test understanding with plain-language explanations or recall questions.
• Use when multiple documents need to be compared without collapsing disagreements into one answer.

When not to use

• The quality of the report cannot exceed the quality and completeness of the source material.
• Scanned PDFs require OCR support from the host environment.
• A clear explanation does not prove that the source's claim is true.
• Source evaluation may require external domain expertise or independent verification.
• Copyrighted material should be summarized and quoted only in limited, necessary excerpts.

Skill page

Conflict

The two copies describe the same five-mode deep-reading workflow but contain material, non-overlapping steps and constraints. The davepoon copy provides specific technical ingestion procedures (PDF stream extraction, WeChat content selectors, 9000-character chunking) and export formats (.md, .mm, .html) that the sickn33 copy lacks. Conversely, the sickn33 copy provides a structured 'Reading Contract,' a detailed 'Evidence Ledger' schema, and a specific 'Feynman Check' verification step that the davepoon copy only references via external files. Because each copy has unique procedural steps that the other lacks, crowning one would hide a real alternative implementation of the skill.