domains / families / research / isca-author-response

isca-author-response

separate

Use when ISCA reviews arrive and the rebuttal-plus-revision window opens — triaging objections by what a three-week window can actually fix, deciding between textual rebuttal and a revised PDF with new experiments, structuring responses that arm a champion at the PC meeting, and avoiding window-burning mistakes.

When to use

• triaging objections by what a three-week window can actually fix
• deciding between textual rebuttal and a revised PDF with new experiments
• structuring responses that arm a champion at the PC meeting
• avoiding window-burning mistakes
• classifying review points into F, E, E∞, D, P, and T classes
• freezing the experiment plan for high-leverage objections
• writing the response document for committee reading
• using the revision half of the window for surgical edits

When not to use

• new contributions beyond the paper's claimed scope
• rebutting every sentence in a review
• premise litigation at length
• simulator relitigating
• restructuring the paper
• spending the window composing indignation

Skill page

Source