domains / families / research / ectheory-rebuttal

ectheory-rebuttal

separate

Use when an Econometric Theory (ET) decision letter arrives and a response strategy and letter are needed — handling proof-checking referee objections, fixing assumptions and gaps, and using the online Supplement, then writing a point-by-point response. It structures the revision, not the proofs themselves.

When to use

• ET decision letter response strategy
• Handling proof-checking referee objections
• Fixing assumptions and gaps
• Using the online Supplement
• Writing a point-by-point response letter
• Structuring the revision
• Prioritizing conflicting referee demands
• Classifying referee comments

When not to use

• Writing the proofs themselves
• Writing the response letter before manuscript proofs reflect fixes
• Promising to address gaps in future work
• Hand-waving disputed steps
• Defensive tone treating proof-check as an attack
• Letting a fix push the Article past 50 pages

Skill page

Source